Side-by-side comparison
Hilton Grand Vacations vs. Vistana (Sheraton / Westin) (2026)
Hilton Grand Vacations Club and Vistana Signature Experiences are both premium points-based timeshare programs, but they're structured very differently. HGVC operates 150+ resorts under the Hilton brand, with the Diamond network now folded in via HGV Max. Vistana operates 20+ Sheraton and Westin-branded resorts under Marriott Vacations Worldwide (since the 2018 acquisition).
Head-to-head
| Attribute | Hilton GV | Vistana |
|---|---|---|
| Currency | HGV Points | StarOptions |
| Parent | Hilton Grand Vacations, Inc. (HGV) | Marriott Vacations Worldwide (acquired 2018) |
| Resort count | 150+ (including Diamond resorts) | 20+ |
| Typical allocation | 2,000–50,000 | 30,000–200,000 |
| Rental value per point | $0.010–$0.025 | $0.025–$0.055 |
The verdict
Which is better?
HGVC wins on resort count and overall network breadth. Vistana wins on Hawaii Westin properties (Ka'anapali, Princeville) and premium Caribbean (St. John). Per-point rental values are in similar zip codes when adjusted for allocation size — HGVC $0.01–$0.025 with larger allocations, Vistana $0.025–$0.055 with smaller. Annual rental yield is comparable. Brand loyalty (Hilton Honors vs Marriott Bonvoy / Sheraton-Westin) is often the deciding factor for new buyers.
Which one fits you?
Pick Hilton GV when:
- ✓Hilton Honors brand alignment matters
- ✓You travel to Hawaii Island, Vegas, or Orlando
- ✓You want HGV Max access to Diamond resorts
- ✓Larger point allocations align with your travel pattern
Pick Vistana when:
- ✓Westin Ka'anapali, Princeville, or St. John are target destinations
- ✓Sheraton or Westin brand consistency matters
- ✓You're considering MVC Destination Points conversion later
- ✓Per-StarOption recovery matters in case you sell
What are your specific points worth?
Free, instant estimate for either program. No signup.
Try the calculator →